
I went to see Beethoven's Fidelio at the Portland Opera last Sunday, and it was good...and bad. What a strange opera -- no wonder Beethoven only wrote one. I think that was probably a good move on his part. The music was decidedly mixed. The opening piece was nicely light and frivolous and set up the "comedy of errors" aspect, the prisoners chorus was musically wonderful. There were a couple of duets and even trios (triets?) that were nicely musically complex. But overall, the music just didn't seem to fit together. This is absolutely no fault of the Portland Opera, but of Ludwig vB, who isn't around to defend himself. In fact, I found the voices to be quite wonderful, especially the close harmony in the prisoners chorus. I found the set quite interesting and thought that the semi-modern setting worked well with the timeless (if a bit predictable) plot of power and corruption, that is, of course, overcome by true love -- very operatic. I did find the spoken lines that were completely said in English rather than even given the attempt at recitativo, along side the music sung in German to be pretty jarring, to the point of sometimes giving a comedic affect where none was intended. All in all, I was very glad to have seen Fidelio, finally, but I am also glad that there aren't more Beethoven operas for me to feel that I have to see. Next up...The Turn of the Screw, by Benjamin Britten. This one will be all in English, another first for me!





